The Pros and Cons of Leaving Half-Eaten Sugar-Free Jello Pudding Out Overnight
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a1152/a11523bce4b2bba00469b373625beb1b0c609f65" alt=""
Pros: no need to worry about attracting any critters.
Cons: it completely liquifies?
Full disclosure: it was Dulce de Leche flavor with the caramel topping. Sugar free caramel topping = imminent death, right?